Replicating an experimental design from Marsden et al. (2018), the present study investigates L1 German speaking EFL learners' implicit and explicit knowledge of the English existential quantifier any. Such knowledge is often explicitly addressed in EFL classroom instruction in terms of the distribution of the polarity items any versus some.
Marsden et al. (2018) found that their Arabic EFL learners could draw on learnt knowledge about this existential quantifier and apparently had also acquired subtle linguistic constraints that had neither been taught nor are systematically represented in the L2 input. Moreover, their Arabic EFL learners did not appear to build both implicit and explicit knowledge around any in a parallel fashion.
The present study replicates and extends Marsden et al. (2018) with the aim of testing whether L1 German-speaking learners at intermediate to advanced proficiency can come to have knowledge of the distribution of any. Similarly to the Arabic-speaking learners in Marsden et al. (2018), such knowledge cannot be derived from the L1. Using both timed acceptability judgements and an extended rule elicitation task, behavioural data were elicited from 100 learners from intermediate to advanced L1 German-speaking learners in tertiary programmes in English. Test items elicited judgement of sentences reflecting taught pedagogical rules (1) and untaught distributional properties (2).
a. Do you want any cake? any in interrogative
b. *Jenny wants any cake. any in positive declarative
a. Jenny denies that she ate any cake. any in complement of negative verb
b. *Jenny thinks that she ate any cake. any in complement of factive verb
While the timed acceptability rating experiment tapped into the learners' implicit knowledge, the untimed rule-elicitation task investigated the extent of learners' conscious awareness of the standard pedagogical rules offered in instruction. By comparing performance on each task, we seek to consider to what extent learners can generalise from explicit input and/or acquire properties that are not clearly represented in the input and not explicitly taught.
The results will be analysed using generalised linear mixed modelling, particularly suited to repeated-measure designs. The results will then be discussed in light of how explicit taught knowledge from instruction may constrain instructed learners' knowledge and in how this knowledge is extended by implicit acquisition despite poverty of the stimulus effects in the distribution of untaught properties of the existential quantifier.
References
Marsden, H., Whong, M., & Gil, K-H. (2018). What's in the textbook and what's in the mind. Polarity item "any" in learner English. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 40(1), 91-118. doi:
10.1017/S0272263117000018.